Summary
Red Dead Redemption 2is largely considered to be a masterpiece of gaming. Its story is an emotional thrill ride that pushed the boundaries of the medium and the world Rockstar created is still one of themost immersive and lifelike video game worldsto date. Despite this, there is one chapter of the game’s story that still divides fans six years later: Guarma.
Fans have criticized the fifth chapter ofRed Dead Redemption 2’s story for breaking up the flow of the game. The player is whisked away to the island after the botched Saint Denis bank job and stripped of their hard-earned gear, weapons, horses, and outfits while completing very on-rail missions. It’s easy to see how and why most fans power through the chapter to get back to the mainland as fast as they can. But there are nuggets of gold hidden in the Guarma chapter and the rest of the game would be worse off without its inclusion.
The Saint Denis bank job is a crucial turning point in the story. The failed robbery sees the Van Der Linde gang take their first major loss to the Pinkertons. The lawmen don’t just put a stop to the score; they apprehend John and kill Lenny and Hosea, two of themoral centers of the Van Der Linde gang. The final mission of Chapter Four is heavy stuff and a lot to take in on a first playthrough.
While some would argue Guarma creates a pacing problem, it’s actually a wonderfully paced segment of the game. The massive slowdown in Chapter Five lets the player really soak in and absorb the events of the previous mission. Rockstar gives a full chapter for the player to stop and languish in the gang’s failure; a full chapter dedicated to grasping how theonce unstoppable Van Der Linde gang had been laid so low.
Guarma is Foreshadowing Dutch’s Fall from Grace
In terms of the story, Guarma is a major shift in the gang’s fortunes, but it also is an excellent piece of character-building forDutch’s slow descent into madness. Guarma was the first time Dutch was really and truly backed into a corner. In high-stress moments like this, people show their true colors and Dutch didn’t disappoint. Most concerning is his immediate desire to jump into the rebel conflict on the island. He frames it as a positive thing; that the rebels’ values are in line with the gang’s and that they’re in the right to help them. But in reality, he’s escalating a conflict he knows little about to further his own selfish goals, in this case getting off the island.
Almost immediately after getting back to the mainland, Dutch starts his largely one-sided relationship with the Wapiti, which, of course, ends in tragedy for the tribe. Guarma serves as an ominous bit of foreshadowing for what Dutch will become in the next chapter and later in the originalRed Dead Redemption. Even ifDutch talks himself up with noble, idealistic language, he ultimately becomes everything he claims to have hated.
Common Arguments Against The Guarma Missions
In subsequent playthroughs, the Guarma sections do become a bit of a chore to slog through. But Chapter Five is one of the shortest inRed Dead Redemption 2, topped only byChapter One’s tutorial-focused missions. What’s more, is that Chapter Five doesn’t even stay in Guarma very long. Four missions are all it takes to get off the island and back to the meat of the game that take less than an hour of gameplay.
Speaking in a strictly pragmatic sense, Guarma does not need to be in the game. There are plenty of other instances in the story where theVan Der Linde gang has to evade the law, and they do so without fleeing the country. But from a narrative/writing standpoint, the time spent in Guarma works flawlessly to convey the isolation and aimlessness the gang is feeling after starting their eventual downfall. TheRed Deadseries has some of the deepest, most well-written characters the medium has to offer, and any time spent with them to gain some more insight into their internal worlds and motivations is time well spent.
Red Dead Redemption 2
WHERE TO PLAY
America, 1899. The end of the wild west era has begun as lawmen hunt down the last remaining outlaw gangs. Those who will not surrender or succumb are killed. After a robbery goes badly wrong in the western town of Blackwater, Arthur Morgan and the Van der Linde gang are forced to flee. With federal agents and the best bounty hunters in the nation massing on their heels, the gang must rob, steal and fight their way across the rugged heartland of America to survive. As deepening internal divisions threaten to tear the gang apart, Arthur must make a choice between his own ideals and loyalty to the gang who raised him. From the creators of Grand Theft Auto V and Red Dead Redemption, Red Dead Redemption 2 is an epic tale of life in America at the dawn of the modern age.
